Article

Bus technology, choices for your city

Across the world there is growing interest in the use of clean, sustainable alternatives to diesel power for buses.

By Steer

Across the world there is growing interest in the use of clean, sustainable alternatives to diesel power for buses. The common driving factor is the environment, with a key factor in Europe being the potential imposition of fines for failing to meet air quality standards. There is also a general desire to reduce carbon emissions and lessen dependency on imported oil-based fuel. 

Buses are rightly perceived as a relatively environmentally friendly means of transportation, but their concentration in cities mean that they are a major contributor to local pollution with negative health impacts. 

Bus manufacturers are actively developing a variety of solutions including alternative fuels (biodiesel, CNG, hydrogen), diesel-electric hybrids with energy storage capability (batteries, ultracapacitors, flywheels), or fully electric (battery, opportunity charge, trolleybus). Meanwhile the environmental performance of diesel engines is improving as a result of progressive tightening of regulations: for example, the latest Euro VI standards deliver ultra-low PM and NOx emissions. 

Technology options are at different stages of development and the pace of progress creates uncertainties about ultimate life-cycle costs, long term performance and risk of obsolescence. Given the significant life of buses and supporting infrastructure, choosing the wrong option could have serious financial implications. What might be right for one city is not necessarily the best solution elsewhere. Local characteristics, including topography, climate, bus speeds, stop frequency and load factors all influence performance and suitability.

Steer Davies Gleave has been assessing the case for introducing new bus technologies and the choice is far from straightforward. Potential environmental benefits are key, but comparisons must be made against up-to-date benchmarks rather than legacy standards. Ultimately the solution must be affordable for those bearing the cost, whether as operators, users or funders. The financial evaluation needs to be on a life cycle cost basis, taking account of initial capital expenditure, energy and maintenance costs, and frequency of renewals. Hybrids are widely reported to achieve fuel savings, but these can vary greatly, depending on route characteristics and the type of buses being replaced. 

Many policy makers want zero emissions at the point of use, but this doesn’t necessarily mean zero or low emissions elsewhere. A high proportion of hydroelectric generation makes achieving genuine zero emissions possible, but relying on electricity generated by fossil fuels could result in more pollution, once transmission and distribution losses are taken into account. 

Range is a limiting factor for any stored energy solution, and the need to charge battery powered vehicles in the depot can severely strain the local electricity supply. Opportunity charging can extend range and allow smaller, lighter batteries, but the infrastructure required has restricted capacity and introduces operating inefficiencies, including extended layover times. Trolleybuses avoid the need for charging, but require costly overhead line and substations that limit operational flexibility. 

Vehicle weight implications also need consideration: even conventional diesel buses can exceed permitted axle loads when fully loaded. Almost all alternative technologies add weight, limiting passenger capacity, requiring more buses and increasing road damage. We have concluded that:

  • Alternative technologies can have an important role to play in reducing harmful emissions in environmentally sensitive areas. 
  • There is no ‘one size fits all’ alternative to the diesel bus, and this is likely to remain the case over the asset life of any bus bought within the next few years; each city will have to find a solution suited to local network characteristics. 
  • While technology is developing rapidly, many claimed benefits remain unproven in fleet-wide application. There is a massive leap between small demonstration projects and the practicalities of wider roll-out. 
  • In many cities, cleaner diesel buses remain a strong contender, especially when ensuring affordability is a core consideration. This doesn’t necessarily mean buying new buses: retrofitting existing buses with emission reduction systems can be particularly cost-effective. 

Our research leads us to believe that the next few years are likely to see more widespread adoption of alternatives to diesel-powered buses. The question is, what is the right solution for your city?

Off

Subscribe to our newsletter, The Edit

We are Steer

Yes, you are in the right place. After 40 years, we have changed our name from Steer Davies Gleave to mark our growing international footprint and our expanding portfolio into sectors beyond transport.

Explore our new website to learn more about Steer: who we are, how we work and what our future holds.

Related insights

  • 24 Jun 2025
    Article

    Steer Supports Launch of Anti-Harassment Protocol for Public Transport in the State of Mexico

    Silvia Mejia
    Silvia Mejia Reza
    Associate & Planning Market Leader for Mexico

    Steer supported a new protocol to tackle sexual harassment on Mexibús, improving safety for users in the State of Mexico.

    Read more

  • 17 Apr 2025
    Article

    Energy from waste: How can local authorities mitigate financial impact of the ETS?

    Viet Nguyen
    Associate Director at Amberside Advisors

    Welcome back to our series exploring the multifaceted world of the Energy from Waste (EfW).

    Read more

  • 18 Jul 2024
    Article

    The King’s Speech: Our key takeaways on planning, transport and the energy transition

    By Steer

    King Charles sets out the new Labour Government’s legislative agenda which intends to ‘take the brakes off Britain’.

    Read more

  • 27 Jun 2024
    Article

    Ten Mobility Challenges for Mexico

    Silvia Mejia
    Silvia Mejia Reza
    Associate & Planning Market Leader for Mexico

    The results of the presidential elections on 2 June invite us to reflect on the challenges facing our cities in terms of planning and

    Read more

  • 26 Apr 2024
    Article

    How can cycling infrastructure be improved in cities around the world? Our consultants give their thoughts

    By Steer

    Last week it was announced that cycling has overtaken car trips as a favoured mode share in central Paris.

    Read more

  • 31 May 2022
    Article

    Crossrail – it wasn’t quick or easy, but it is wonderful

    Adrian Cole
    Consulting Director
    Victoria Rees
    Associate Director

    As Crossrail completes its first week of passenger service, it's a good opportunity to reflect on the work that led to this milestone.

    Read more

  • 21 Apr 2021
    Article

    Is flexibility the answer?

    Undoubtedly, the COVID-19 pandemic has imposed a sudden stop to our daily routine and reshaped our mobility needs and priorities.

    Read more

  • 06 Apr 2021
    Article

    Public sector support stimulus on mobility policy post-COVID in Italy

    Raffael Massa
    Raffael Massa
    Associate Director & Head of Financial Advisory, Italy

    New rules for public transport have impacted public mobility demand, leading people to reconsider the use of cars.

    Read more

  • 19 Jan 2021
    Article

    Investing for future generations

    Neil Chadwick
    Director

    The DfT has been consulting on whether it should extend the appraisal period for transport schemes beyond the current 60 years.

    Read more

  • 21 Dec 2020
    Article

    Our Urban Dynamic Model reimagined for COVID-19

    By Steer

    Our Urban and Regional Dynamic Models have been reimagined for COVID-19.

    Read more

  • 26 Nov 2020
    Article

    Better thinking for levelling up

    Neil Chadwick
    Director

    How the UK Government appraises its spending decisions and subsequently evaluates these.

    Read more

  • 04 Nov 2020
    Article

    Bus and rail after COVID-19: November update

    Neil Chadwick
    Director

    Yesterday we set out three factors that we think will determine the future rate and scale of public transport use.

    Read more